Thursday 26 April 2012

Are Short Stories Dead


Having a full time job and being someone who enjoys writing, I never find enough time in a day to properly sit down and write to a great extent, I always seem to wind up a story before I lose the flow. There is nothing worse than having a great idea and going on until you kill it because the enthusiasm has been lost, due to a bitty writing schedule.

Managing between three and ten thousand words to finalise a story is where I feel my limited time allows me to safely conclude a story without it turning into spaghetti. But how could I possibly make any kind of money out of that?

Magazine Submissions, the submission process is easy enough taking care to format the submission in the specific way they require, however some magazines want only unpublished works to be submitted, a fair enough comment, but their process takes months and in that time what do you do? Also does this make the story redundant after it has been published once.

Self-publishing, a great resource if you are blessed with the time to add, Self-Marketing and Promotions, finding markets, creating visuals, choosing the edition type for example kindle, eBook PDFs or iBooks etc.

On a blog, again self-promotion required and where does the financial incentive come from, small adverts like Google Adwords that give you a click through rate or a commission on the follow through sale. This only works in two ways, specifically selected advertising for the target audience and if the audience click the adverts.

But what about the physical story, three to ten thousand words in self-publish terms could be a few hours out of someone’s day or split across a couple of days, then it is gone. Will someone pay a small contribution for a short story when, for a small amount more you could get a Novel published by the big companies and written by fully fledged, time served authors?

But the short story will only work in any or all of the above if the target audience will read it. I did some of the above except I placed 5 short stories in kindle formatted collection. I did mention that I enjoy writing and as my twitter bio says, “I enjoy writing, doesn't mean I am any good at it.” I don’t classify myself as an author, I also would never suggest to anyone that I am into marketing or promotions. I probably couldn't even write the sales worthy, descriptive text on my own short collection. The sales of my 5 unUsual Short Stories are negligible. In reality, my commission doesn't buy me a pint of milk. Maybe it is early days, only time will tell me that. But what is a short story, we could look it up but you will find varying definitions of a short story, Wikipedia will tell you them all. But when you think about it, the bible is full of short stories, I am sure the Kings of old where told short stories by wandering minstrels. So from the beginning of time any tale that held the attention of an audience could be classified as a Short Story. In publishing terms the word count will determine the thresholds of flash fiction, short stories, novella and a novel.

Short stories in general are a great way to have short burst of excitement, adventure, romance and be able to carry on with a busy day. Even the big authors have written short stories, Charles Dickens, Edgar Allen Poe, The Brothers Grimm and Homer have all written short stories. These are historical authors and have the names that we recognise, but even in this modern era the big authors are at it too. From the fifties to the modern day authors like Stephen King, Daphne Du Maurier, JD Sallinger and Roald Dahl are known for writing short stories.

Are short stories dead, the question to answer, my thoughts are no of course not they are the cornerstone of everyone’s imagination. You may think that you do not have enough of an imagination to tell a story, but if you can think you can tell a story. But can short stories be a marketable thing, that is a bigger question.

?

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

Short stories are good for competitions and performance readings. Generally speaking, short stories (even novellas) do not sell particularly well, which is a great shame. Even established and famous authors have to sell "shorts" as collections.

I suspect we can thank the "old guard" publishing industry for this; it remains to be seen how the ebook/indie markets react to them! As you say, early days yet.

Regards

Nick Rose

Pcrtrg said...

Nick,

I am in total agreement and maybe if I applied myself a little more and learnt more about the indie/ebook publishing market I could stand a better chance of increasing the sales of mine.

A great point well put. Let all short story writers stand up and wave their metaphorical quills in the air.

Appreciate it.

Paul

James E. Parker said...

I've often wondered how well short stories to financially in the ebook format. I feel you pain Paul, even focusing my efforts more on novels, there are so many choices for publishing out there now. Do you put all your chips on the table and trust your work to the large publishing houses? I know that is betting against all odds that if the skies part and miracles happen and you do get published, then you still have to trust they will faithfully market your book to biggest possible audience. But the Indie route is just as laden with fears. Without 10K plus followers on twitter and hundreds of people reading our blogs, how does one generate a profitable following? Thanks for asking the hard questions and being honest about writing man. It is encouraging.
Jim

James E. Parker said...

WOW! can you tell I'm a writer from all those mistakes in that last post? lol. I've got to stop depending on my wife for all my proof reading.